Diapers are one thing no one likes having to buy. Undoubtedly, it’s a necessity. The alternative is unthinkable and messy. Still, by the time a child reaches the training pants stage, parents are grateful. They can finally see the light at the end of the tunnel. Training pants are used to transition between diapers and normal underwear.
They are worn during potty training. Potty training can be an overwhelming time for parents and children alike. No one wants to have to worry about the reliability of their chosen training pants. Choosing the right brand can be the difference between a stress-free process and a hectic one.
Pampers and Huggies are the biggest names in the diaper game. Pampers brand training pants are called Easy Ups. The Huggies version is known as Pull-Ups. At first glance, the products seem the same. How much difference can there be, after all? Surprisingly, there are plenty of differences! While browsing parent reviews, clear pros and cons for each brand keep popping up.
- Durable design
- Soft material that mimics underwear
- Stretchy comfortable fit
- Gentle on sensitive skin
- Leak guards and absorbent channels
- Pants tear easily open at sides
- Not true to size
- No wetness indicators
- Larger size range (starts at 12 months)
- Wetness indicators
- Side Velcro can be reclosed
- True to size
- Customer complaints of skin rashes
- Don’t look or feel like underwear
- Not much stretch
When placed next to each other, these two types of training pants look very different. They feature different printed cartoon characters, but the designs of the pants themselves differ. Many parents prefer the soft stretchy material of Pampers Easy Ups. They mimic real underwear closely. Easy Ups feature a 360-degree stretch, just like elastic underwear would have. This could mean a more comfortable fit.
Huggies Pull-Ups still feel “diaper-like,” according to reviews. It lacks the elasticity of the Pampers version. Even so, Huggies Pull-Ups have features that can make potty training easier. Pull-Ups feature a graphic on the front that disappears once it’s wet. Huggies also produces the Cool and Learn training pants. With these pants, toddlers experience a brief cooling sensation. This short damp feeling mimics the feel of a leak in regular underpants.
Training pants are not as absorbent as diapers, no matter the brand. Accidents do happen, though, and a training pant needs to handle them.
The Pampers Easy Ups boast the brand’s trademarked Dual LeakGuard barriers. These barriers absorb around the legs, where most accidents occur. The training pants also have Extra Absorb Channels that distribute wetness evenly.
Huggies Pull-Ups offer specialized protection for boys and girls. The boy version includes extra absorbent padding higher up in the front. Meanwhile, the girl Pull Up has more absorbency in the gusset area. This specialized protection can help during daytime use. Many critical reviews, though, mention overnight leakage.
Pampers Easy Ups promises “up to 12 hours of protection.” It’s a bold claim. The brand’s absorbency measures do work. “It’s amazing how much they absorb,” reads a Pampers review by Jessica. “These are great for those who have issues with overnight leakage.”
Still, how accurate is 12 hours of protection? The reviews are mixed. User Aashish’s review only gave the product two stars. “My three year old [was] soaked in urine [in] just 3 hours.” Meanwhile, grandmother Shelly’s review assures that Pampers is the only brand that keeps her grandson dry overnight. “I will only use Pampers for all my grandchildren [and] great-grandchildren,” writes Shelly.
Huggies Pull-Ups may not stand the nighttime test. In fact, Huggies offers a separate product for overnight use. Pull-Ups Night*Time training pants offer the brand’s “most absorbent pant.” This claim comes straight from the official website. Reviews for the nighttime pants are generally glowing. Still, consumers may not want to have two types of training pants on hand.
Pampers are not true to size. Many parents find they run small. Parents of petite children rejoice fact this in the reviews. Toddlers with larger size needs though may be uncomfortable in Pampers Easy Ups. Customer Angel writes: “I have a 2-year-old training right now, and none of your training pants fit him. I have tried multiple sizes, and none of them cover his bottom.”
Huggies Pull-Ups offer a variety of sizes. Huggies Pull-Ups come in 12 – 24-month sizes. The smallest size in Easy Ups is 2T. Huggies Pull-Ups allows younger potty trainers to enjoy training pants too. The Velcro sides offer flexibility in size. A customer known by username Anyer227 prefers Huggies and its Velcro sides. She can adjust the size using the Velcro.
Keeping it Sensitive
Babies and toddlers famously have sensitive skin. Their skin is still new, after all! Doctors warn parents to avoid anything heavily perfumed or particularly irritating. Some kids are more affected than others. 1 in 3 children will experience extremely sensitive skin. For those children, they need a training pant that won’t cause skin issues. Parents everywhere praise the Pampers brand for its gentleness.
Laura gives five stars to Pampers Pull-Ups on behalf of her daughter. “[Easy Ups are] the only ones that keep my daughter dry without a rash. We’ve tried several brands. [Pull-Ups] gave my baby girl a rash several times!” Other parents had the same complaint about Huggies Pull-Ups. One mother, Nikki, left a review on the Huggies official site. After three days of wearing Pull-Ups, Nikki had to treat her child for a severe skin rash. Plenty of children without sensitivity issues do wear Huggies without an issue, though. When it comes to sensitive skin, trial and error is sometimes the only way to know.
What about being hypoallergenic? Unfortunately, neither Pampers nor Huggies promises their training pants are hypoallergenic. For infants, Pampers offers its Pampers Pure Protection line. These diapers are clinically proven to be hypoallergenic. Huggies Little Snugglers diapers are intended for newborns and are also hypoallergenic. Still, neither brand offers this benefit in their training pants. If this feature is important, consider another brand.
Which Training Pant is Superior?
As with diapers, training pants are all about trial and error. It’s all about the comfort of the toddler who has to wear the pants! It’s important to consider the above features and decide what product suits your toddler.